Study finds Apple Watch is most accurate wearable at measuring heart rate

by Buster Hein May 24, 2017

When it comes to measuring heart rate and calories burned, not all fitness trackers are created equal, based on the findings of a scientific study that pitted the top wearables on the market against each other.

The in-depth study conducted by researchers at Stanford University was published today, revealing that Apple Watch is the most accurate wrist-worn tracker on the market, but it’s still far from perfect.

In their paper titled “Accuracy in Wrist-Worn, Sensor-Based Measurements of Heart Rate and Energy Expenditure in a Diverse Cohort,” researchers evaluated the Apple Watch, Basis Peak, Fitbit Surge, Microsoft Band, Mio Alpha 2, PulseOn, and Samsung Gear watch chart

Researchers concluded that Apple Watch achieved the lowest overall errors when measuring both heart rate and energy expended. Samsung did the worse overall with the Gear S2 reporting the highest amount of errors for both fields.

The study found that the wrist-worn trackers had the lowest error rate when a person was cycling. Walking provided the highest amount of errors.

Six of the seven devices tested all achieved a median heart rate error below 5%. Tracking calories burned is much tricker though. Not a single device tested had an error rate below 20 percent, so if you’re trying to use your Apple Watch or FitBit to count calories, you probably need to find a more accurate method.

Buster Hein
Buster Hein


Leave a comment

Comments will be approved before showing up.

Also in Learn about your Apple Watch

Luck o’ the Irish: Save 20 percent on green Apple Watch bands [Watch Store]

by Ami Icanberry March 17, 2018

As St. Patrick’s Day imbibing commences, Cult of Mac offers up all things green for your Apple Watch band-buying pleasure. We’ve scoured the Watch Store to feature eight special bands in green from these great companies: Casetify, Clessant, E3 Supply Co. and Ullu. Today only, save 20 percent on these Irish-inspired Apple Watch bands by […]

Continue Reading

Stylish, portable Pod Pro keeps Apple Watch ready to go [Watch Store]

by Ami Icanberry March 15, 2018

Charging the Apple Watch while traveling can be a little tricky. Generally, I lug along a super-long charging cable and a wall plug to get the job done when on holiday. Nomad — makers of great Apple Watch straps and accessories — offers a stylish and super-portable charging solution called the Pod Pro. The Pod Pro wraps […]

Continue Reading

Take your running to new heights with the altimeter in Apple Watch Series 3

by Graham Bower March 13, 2018

Are you taking full advantage of all the neat new features in your shiny Series 3 Apple Watch? Cellular connectivity grabbed the headlines, but that isn’t the only hardware addition Cupertino managed to cram into a wearable that was already bristling with sensors. Apple Watch Series 3 models also boast a barometric altimeter. If you […]

Continue Reading